It’s officially pumpkin spice season, and for many of us in New York, that means one thing, coffee runs are back in full swing. Whether you’re grabbing your PSL on the way to work or settling in at your favorite neighborhood spot, that warm, cinnamon-y sip is basically fall in a cup. But if your wallet’s been feeling a little lighter lately, you’re not imagining it. According to a new study, New York tops the list for the most expensive Pumpkin Spice Latte in the entire country.

The Price of Fall Comfort in the Empire State

Researchers compared Starbucks prices in 50 major U.S. cities, and here’s the headline: New Yorkers are shelling out nearly $8 for a Grande Pumpkin Spice Latte. That’s the highest price tag in America. It’s a steep price for whipped cream and nostalgia but this is New York, after all. We’re used to paying a premium for the good stuff. Still, it stings a little knowing that someone in, say, Phoenix or Dallas is sipping the exact same drink for a couple bucks less.

READ MORE: New York’s Top 5 Pumpkin Treats Everyone’s Searching For This Fall

New Yorkers Don’t Have to Go Far for Their PSL

While the price is high, convenience is one thing New Yorkers can’t complain about. The same study looked at which cities make it easiest to get your Starbucks fix measuring everything from how many stores are packed into a city to how close they are to home. The study found that in many parts of the state, Starbucks locations are so tightly clustered that your next latte is never more than a few minutes away. It’s practically part of the morning routine: a walk, a podcast, and a PSL in hand.

Star 93.9 logo
Get our free mobile app

New Yorkers Know a PSL Is Worth Every Sip

So yes, New Yorkers may be paying top dollar for their pumpkin spice lattes, but are we really going to stop ordering them? Probably not. There’s something about that first sip of fall that makes it all worth it. The PSL has officially become part of New York’s autumn identity. So go ahead and treat yourself. Just maybe check your bank account before you order that second one.

A Brilliant Pumpkin Showcase in Central New York!

We love to decorate our houses and businesses with bright orange pumpkins during the autumn season in Upstate New York. And, a homemade pumpkin pie can be seen gracing almost every harvest table during the season. But pumpkin culinary creations have a long list of varieties limited only by your imagination. Here are some of the best to be found in Central New York: Pumpkin bread, latte, pies, muffins, lattes, muffins and a whole lot more!

Look Around the Upstate New York Cider Mill Named Among the Best Cideries in America

Fly Creek Cider Mill & Orchard has been crowned the #3 best cidery in America by readers of USA Today. Take a peek around the grounds!

Gallery Credit: Traci Taylor

More From Star 93.9